Carrier Claims Contact Info

As a Consolidated Insurance, Inc. personal insurance policy holder you have the option of contacting our agency at 219-866-5129 during business hours or directly contact your carrier below 24 hours a day.

Company Main Claims
Safeco Insurance Co. of America 800-332-3226
American Modern 800-375-2075
Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield IN Please call the Member Service number on the back of your Member ID Card.
Assurant Health 800-553-7654
Auto-Owners Insurance Co. 800-346-0346
Foremost 800-333-7276
Hanover Insurance Co. Personal: 800-628-0250
Business: 800-628-0250
Indiana Insurance 800-279-7221
Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. 800-526-1547
Ohio Casualty 866-255-5530
Ohio Casualty Insurance Co. 866-255-5530
Progressive 800-776-4737
Progressive Commercial 800-274-4499
Sagamore Personal: 800-317-9402
Trucking: 800-224-1221
Scottsdale Insurance Co. 800-423-7675
Symetra 800-796-3872
Zurich 800-987-3373